Franklin Templeton: Springtime for Japanese stocks

Japan may be blossoming again. Goods and wage inflation are returning, some companies are embracing real and significant corporate reforms, the equity market has surged, and foreign investors are showing sustained enthusiasm. Nonetheless, we believe investors in the Japanese market still need to be selective when searching for companies that can unlock value as not every firm is fully, or enthusiastically, warming to change.

Goods-and-wage inflation flower

The Japanese economy appears to us to be emerging from years of stagnation. We believe a rebound in inflation in both goods and wages should help the country boost economic dynamism and spark a period of hotter and more sustained growth.

Corporate Japan has shown a greater willingness and ability to raise prices and overall inflation is now approaching the Bank of Japan’s (BoJ’s) 2% target. (See Exhibit 1).

Exhibit 1: Monthly Japanese Consumer Price Index Climbs

Monthly Japanese Consumer Price Index
February 2018–February 2024

Source: Statistics Bureau of Japan.

Wage growth, which has lagged price increases, is also starting to climb as companies need to pay their employees more to afford costlier goods. The spring labor negotiations suggest a significant wage hike for Japanese workers in the coming year. Labor unions secured a 5.24% average total wage hike through three rounds of negotiations, up from an average wage increase of 3.6% in 2023, according to Rengo, the Japanese Trade Union Confederation. (See Exhibit 2).

Exhibit 2: Japanese Wage Increases Accelerate

Japanese Wage Increases Accelerate
February 2013–April 2024

Source: Japanese Trade Union Confederation.

Crucially, we believe higher wages can help end the negative spiral of falling prices and stagnant wages the economy has been in over the past few decades and move it to a place where inflation is expected to be structurally sustained at positive levels. Dynamism could return to the Japanese economy as a result.  

Interest rates begin to bud

With inflation in both goods and wages picking up, the BoJ ended decades of experimental monetary policy and negative interest rates in late March. For the first time since 2007, it raised rates to a 0-0.1% range. The central bank also reduced quantitative easing measures.

While we view this move as a small step, we believe the BoJ will continue to gradually normalize monetary policy over the next couple of years. If it turns out that the economy starts to improve, wages rise and modest inflation remains a regular occurrence, then we would expect the BoJ to take additional steps to tighten monetary policy.

Corporate reforms bloom

At the same time the economy is improving, corporate Japan is beginning to embrace change, spurred on by the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE). The TSE is encouraging companies to improve their returns and reduce their cost of capital as part of a push to make the country more investable. Furthermore, new rules will push companies to simultaneously release earnings and other disclosures in English, making the market more appealing to overseas, non-Japanese speaking investors.

While the exchange has had a good initial response from most large-cap companies in laying out their plans, smaller companies have not been as forthcoming, in our view. The Tokyo Stock Exchange expects to keep pushing companies that have not fully put forward plans to reduce their cost of capital to eventually do so. We are naturally more interested in the companies that have realistic plans which, if successful, we expect can drive tremendous long-term returns for shareholders.

There is much work to do in Japan as a third of companies have price-to-book ratios below one and low returns on equity. Of the 4,015 active stocks on the Tokyo Stock Exchange at the end of March, about 39% have price-to-book values below one, while 34% of companies have a return on equity of less than 5%, according to data from FactSet.

The TSE and the Japanese government are also pushing companies to reduce their cross-shareholdings, which are widely seen as a barrier to market efficiency and transparency, as well as a barrier to mergers and acquisitions. These holdings have been common in Japan for decades, as companies held stock in their customers and vice versa to cement and maintain business relationships. While this system has worked for the individual Japanese companies themselves, it has not typically worked for anyone else, including investors.

We have seen some companies unwind their holdings while others have just begun to consider their own plans. Although the changes have been slow, as more companies make real progress on this front, we would expect momentum to continue to build until real change blooms.

While reducing cross-shareholdings is a positive, we want to see what companies do with the cash from these sales. Those firms that want to buy growth at home or overseas look less appealing to us on first blush, given Japanese companies’ poor record of overseas acquisitions, than those that may return cash to shareholders through stock buybacks or fatter dividends.  

Blossoming value stock opportunities

Enthusiasm about these corporate and economic changes in Japan has spilled over into the equity market, with the MSCI Japan rising sharply since the start of 2023 (see Exhibit 3). While we believe enthusiasm for Japan is justified, finding compelling value opportunities after the runup will require careful stock selection.

Exhibit 3: Japanese Stocks Rally in 2023 and Early 2024

Japanese Stocks Rally in 2023 and Early 2024
March 29, 2019–March 26, 2024

Sources: FactSet, MSCI. MSCI makes no warranties and shall have no liability with respect to any MSCI data reproduced herein. Indexes are unmanaged and one cannot directly invest in them. They do not include fees, expenses or sales charges. Past performance is not an indicator or a guarantee of future results.  See www.franklintempletondatasources.com for additional data provider information.

We believe companies that have a clear plan to improve their returns and reduce their cost of capital, and that are willing to buy back stock trading below book following the unwinding of cross-shareholdings, are more appealing than those that are simply posturing. Additionally, companies that are managing toward a medium-term growth plan and capital allocation strategy can be better judged on their success.

In our view, the companies that are successful could see a significant runway for growth and potential stock price appreciation as book values improve over the medium term. This burgeoning Japanese spring could turn into a long summer.

Endnotes

1. Source: Bank of Japan, March 19, 2024.

WHAT ARE THE RISKS?

 All investments involve risks, including possible loss of principal.

Equity securities are subject to price fluctuation and possible loss of principal.. Active management does not ensure gains or protect against market declines.

International investments are subject to special risks, including currency fluctuations and social, economic and political uncertainties, which could increase volatility.